All News

Daily Bridge in New Zealand

 

For Less Experienced Players:  Minor Nightmare!

 

Well, it should have been a fun hand. You have 13 cards distributed as evenly as possible among the two minor suits, two decent suits as well, as both were headed by the KQ..and partner had opened the bidding. It was just a case of finding a fit and then bidding to…the appropriate level, whatever that was. “Just” proved to be a tad awkward. Our partner was not co-operating!

Bridge in NZ.pngnz map.jpg

 

     
North Deals
N-S Vul
 
N
W   E
S
   
 
K Q 5 4 3 2
K Q 8 7 6 5 3
West North East South
  1  Pass 2 
Pass 2  Pass 3 
Pass 3 NT Pass ?

 

No, I did not make this hand up. It happened, very recently! What to do? Let partner stew in 3NT?

It would seem our partner has 6 hearts with a hold at least in spades. They do not appear to have a very strong hand as 2Heart-small was a limit bid, to say 15 high card points at the most, probably less. They may have an ace in one of the minor suits, or they may not!

At some tables, South gave up and hoped their partner could conjure up 9 tricks from somewhere. They could not with this contract going between 2 and 4 down. It does not follow that if one partner has both major suits and the other both minor suits that a no-trump contract will make or be easy to play. It was a nightmare for the declarers.

arguing.png

we just do not communicate well.

Take a look:

 

 

North Deals
N-S Vul
A Q 7 5
A J 9 8 4 3
J 10
10
K 8 6 3 2
6 5 2
A 7 6
A 4
 
N
W   E
S
 
J 10 9 4
K Q 10 7
9 8
J 9 2
 
K Q 5 4 3 2
K Q 8 7 6 5 3
West North East South
  1  Pass 2 
Pass 2  Pass 3 
Pass 3 NT Pass ?

 

Against 3NT, the defence should not make it easy for North, even on an apparently friendly Spade-smallJ lead. North’s best chance would be if West ducked the first round of clubs and declarer led an inspired low club from dummy on the second round.

However, even if that happened, while North tried to get to dummy by overtaking diamonds twice, in the meantime, the defence will take three spade tricks and two aces. That’s the best result for North. As you can see above, in reality it was much worse.

The more minor cards that North has the better it will be for South and if North does not have many, then communication between the two hands will range from the very difficult to the absolutely impossible. Thus, South must never pass 3NT. They have to keep ploughing on, bidding the minors until their partner finally gets the message.

A bid of 4Diamond-small after 3NT would confirm at least 5 diamonds and therefore because South started with clubs, longer clubs, at least 11 cards in the minor suits. North would not be very impressed by that bid though despite the result on the board, this bid could/should not be passed. For all North knew, their partner might have one or both aces on top of their existing holding.

Having said North should bid, what should they choose? 5Diamond-small may be a 5-2 fit while 5Club-small a 6-1 fit, neither very appealing. 4Heart-small was beginning to look a poor choice. As you can see, it does not matter which choice North makes since both minor suits should be defeated by one trick.

In 5Club-small, there are two trump tricks for the defence and the Diamond-smallA as long as West does not lead Club-smallA. In 5Diamond-small, there are the same three tricks, though West does have to play Diamond-smallA and a second diamond to prevent South from ruffing a club in dummy.

Giving preference with a singleton, especially at the 5 level, may seem like a strange concept, though it would prove a much better option than bidding 4Heart-small, although South should really continue with 5Club-small over that bid, because of the freakish nature of their hand. At that point, even the most confused North would have to give up.

“It sounds, partner, that you have 13 cards in the minors, the way you kept bidding” North was heard to exclaim as they laid down dummy. “Watch this space” came the amused reply.

A Small Distortion

The bidding to 5 of a minor,either minor, as shown above is fine. However, South might construct a better auction if they pretended their diamonds were longer or at least the same length as their clubs by bidding diamonds first:

 

                        North                        South

 

                        1Heart-small                               2Diamond-small

 

                        2Heart-small                              3Club-small

 

                        3NT                            4Club-small

 

A fit of some kind could be established at the 4Diamond-small level, rather more comfortably for North. It would then be left to South to hope their partner can produce a minor ace and chance slam, or more sensibly, just raise to 5Diamond-small…and go quietly one down.

So, stopping in 4 of a minor was the right action this time though with such a hand as South, most of the time they would like to be at least in game. No North-South pair did achieve a plus score though those who played 5 of a minor scored much better than those in 3NT or 4Heart-small.

bid on.jpg

 

Don’t stop…keep on bidding!

Bring on the 4333 7-counts! No way! I am sure it was fun bidding the above hands and even, unless you were in 3NT or 4H, quite nice to play them too.

On defence

You have to some of the time. It can be challenging. So, here’s a challenge:

 
North Deals
E-W Vul
8 4 3
A K 9 3
Q 6 3
7 5 4
A 2
8 7 4 2
7 5
A K J 6 3
 
N
W   E
S
   
West North East South
you dummy    
  Pass Pass 1 
2  2  Pass 3 
Pass 4  All pass  

 

You lead Club-smallK and partner shows you an even number as declarer plays Club-smallQ. A second high club sees South ruff, play Heart-smallJ to dummy’s ace (Heart-small6 from partner..low encourage) and then Spade-small3 to Spade-small6, declarer’s Spade-small10…over to you.

 

Richard Solomon

 

Go Back View All News Items

Our Sponsors
  • Tauranga City Council
  • TECT.jpg