All News

TALES OF AKARANA

Crashing Honours

A series of curious events resulted in 12 well won imps on the following board (4). In the cold and reflective light of the post-mortem, one can find a reason why the defence could have prevailed but the declarer, Carol Richardson, gave them the scope to misdefend…and misdefend they did.

Firstly, playing strong no-trump and a 2+ 1Club-small opening, what would you respond after hearing your partner open 1Club-small? You hold:

Spade-small AQ53

Heart-small A63

Diamond-small983

Club-small Q87

and there is no opposition bidding? I am sure 1Spade-small would be the choice of most. Absolutely perfect. Carol chose to use Hamman’s Rule that 3NT might be the best game to bid and make. She used the “tell them nothing” maxim too. The immediate 3NT bid should deny a four card major and have a hold in each other suit. Well, the above hand did not quite fit the bill in two respects...but the heart and club holdings seemed fine!

Everyone passed and on receiving the Heart-smallJ lead from South, this is what she saw, as East.

Board 4
West Deals
Both Vul
   
K 7 6
K 9
A J 10
J 6 5 4 3
 
N
W   E
S
 
A Q 5 3
A 6 3
9 8 3
Q 8 7
West North East South
1  Pass 3 NT All pass

 

She thanked partner for dummy (“nice clubs!”) and ducked the first heart. North won with the queen and continued Heart-small8. You are in dummy. What now?

Even if she made 4 spade and 2 diamond tricks, she still needed a trick from the club suit. That could be a long time in coming. She hastened that time by leading Club-smallJ from dummy!

Board 4
West Deals
Both Vul
10 2
Q 8
K 7 5 4 2
A 10 9 2
K 7 6
K 9
A J 10
J 6 5 4 3
 
N
W   E
S
 
A Q 5 3
A 6 3
9 8 3
Q 8 7
 
J 9 8 4
J 10 7 5 4 2
Q 6
K
West North East South
1  Pass 3 NT All pass

 

You can debate the rights and wrongs of this play but when North decided to cover one honour with another, the fall of a third honour from South spelt the end for the defence. There was no time now for North to switch to the contract- defeating diamond suit and South’s hearts were well and truly dead.

Carol was able to win North’s lead and establish dummy’s clubs for just one more loser..making 9 tricks. Most of the tables saw West as declarer and received a diamond lead. Not even a “high club crescendo” could save them from five losers. Indeed, some went down in 2NT.

Carol got lucky in that the diamond suit was with North but she rode this piece of luck well with an inspired first bid and then club play.

Richard Solomon

 

 

 

 

 

 

Go Back View All News Items

Our Sponsors
  • Tauranga City Council
  • TECT.jpg